Bug #324

No sound on ICH4 when snd_ich loaded after acpi on T41p

Added by dgerow about 8 years ago. Updated over 7 years ago.

Status:ClosedStart date:
Priority:NormalDue date:
Assignee:-% Done:

0%

Category:-
Target version:-

Description

I've just installed 1.6.1 on an IBM T41p (type 2373), and sound doesn't work
if snd_ich.ko is loaded after acpi.ko.

If I boot the system normally, then load snd_ich.ko, the module loads, but
nothing is registered to dmesg, and the contents of /dev/sndstat are:

FreeBSD Audio Driver (newpcm)
Installed devices:

And that's it. If I load snd_ich.ko via loader.conf, I get full sound
without issue (see attachments for details). However, if I remove
snd_ich.ko and snd_pcm.ko, then reload them, I see the same as before: they
load, but register nothing to dmesg, and nothing shows up in /dev/sndstat.

Attachments can also be found at:

<https://yibbidy.afflictions.org/~dgerow/itsdloan30-lt/uname.txt>
<https://yibbidy.afflictions.org/~dgerow/itsdloan30-lt/dmesg.txt>
<https://yibbidy.afflictions.org/~dgerow/itsdloan30-lt/pciconf.txt>

in case they don't read properly as attachments.

dmesg.txt Magnifier (27.4 KB) dgerow, 09/21/2006 10:28 PM

pciconf.txt Magnifier (3.77 KB) dgerow, 09/21/2006 10:28 PM

uname.txt Magnifier (172 Bytes) dgerow, 09/21/2006 10:28 PM

History

#1 Updated by tautolog about 8 years ago

The same things happens to me, and has been happening for a while. I
am not sure what version it started (seems after 1.4), but it worked
before. I have not had much time to investigate it. swildner helped me
with it on IRC. It happens on my work box, which I don't have access
to at the moment, but I can provide details later if needed.

On 9/21/06, Damian Gerow <> wrote:
> I've just installed 1.6.1 on an IBM T41p (type 2373), and sound doesn't work
> if snd_ich.ko is loaded after acpi.ko.
>

#2 Updated by corecode over 7 years ago

does this still happen on -preview or -devel?

#3 Updated by dgerow over 7 years ago

Thus spake Simon 'corecode' Schubert () [24/01/07 04:57]:
: does this still happen on -preview or -devel?

I'm not sure. I no longer have a T41p to test on.

#4 Updated by corecode over 7 years ago

closing for now, possibly fixed in -devel.

#5 Updated by civilizd over 7 years ago

I'm confirming that this was fixed. (Works with today's build)

Also available in: Atom PDF