missing 's0' in device use
After change to use s0 for 'compatibility' slice, as described
in UPDATING, its use need to be changed in a few places.
A few small patches attached.
ccdconfig(8) man page, EXAMPLES section, also may need changes,
I didn't test yet, but it has several uses like /dev/da3e,
which I guess should be /dev/da3s0e.
disklabel should use ccd0 (or maybe ccd0s0), not ccd0c.
Also it would be nice to have info about this in a man page,
not just in UPDATING. But which man page?
On the same note, it would be really nice to have usage of slice number
for device nodes in a man page. Eg. MBR s1 - s4 primary/extended slices and s5
upward are in extended slices.
#1 Updated by thomas.nikolajsen about 9 years ago
I have looked into this; think I'm finished for now.
New patches attached:
forgot one place in prev. patch.
- ccd(4), ccdconfig(8)
tested, not just guessing.
I have called 's0' for 'compatibility slice',
other (w/ positive slice number) 'normal slice'.
Terms used was: 'base disk/raw disk' and 'slice';
this had to change if 's0' is called a slice, which seems natural.
I'm not sure s0 always technically is a compatibility slice;
eg. for vn0s0 or ccd0s0; if other terms should be used,
give me a hint or just change it.
Also first disklabel example is changes a bit:
a ccd partition is added (we don't use 4.2BSD for that any more),
and an error is fixed: sizes and offsets didn't add up correctly.
- disklabel64(5), disklabel64(8)
Minimal changes: just to show disklabel64; not 'disklabel'
(which I think is confusing at best).
I could make a more elaborate patch if needed
(including same change for disklabel64.c).
- vinum(4), vinum(8)
This isn't tested yet; will do that.
's0' is added to devicenames without;
I guess this is correct as eg. /dev/da1h doesn't exist any more.
Also disklabel output for a vinum partition is dropped,
as preceeding text says it server no useful purpose.
(if needed I could change output to current form instead).
A few comments on ccd(4) are updated.
I came to think about that information on changed disk device use,
is only in /usr/src/UPDATING, which isn't on release CD.
I think easiest solution would be to just copy UPDATING to root of CD.
PS: It could be really nice it this could be committed ASAP and MFC'ed,
so it could hit the next release update
(Matt talked about this coming week-end for mbuf fix).
#2 Updated by swildner about 9 years ago
Uh, I looked into this for some time and ended up frustrated. For
example, shouldn't it then also be
disklabel [-r] slice
disklabel [-r] disk
I'm kinda confused over adjusting disklabel.8.
Not committed. Is this tested yet?
Yea, that would be a good thing.
#3 Updated by nthery about 9 years ago
There is also a missing 's0' in vkernel man page.
--- dfly.orig/src/share/man/man7/vkernel.7 2007-07-24 16:02:10.000000000 +0200
+++ dfly/src/share/man/man7/vkernel.7 2007-08-08 13:25:00.000000000 +0200
@@ -291,7 +291,7 @@
make installworld DESTDIR=/mnt
make distribution DESTDIR=/mnt
-echo '/dev/vkd0a / ufs rw 1 1' >/mnt/etc/fstab
+echo '/dev/vkd0s0a / ufs rw 1 1' >/mnt/etc/fstab
#5 Updated by nthery about 9 years ago
Well, when I "ls /dev/vkd0*", I get:
/dev/vkd0 /dev/vkds0 /dev/vkds0a ...
There is no /dev/vkd0a printed.
First time I configured the vkernel, I referred to an old version of
vkernel.7 and had to manually add 's0' to some other commands so after
checking /dev as shown above I added it in /etc/fstab too and it's
been running ok since.
However, I've just put /dev/vkd0a in /etc/fstab and it works too.
Is 's0' somehow added by mount or the kernel?
#7 Updated by nthery about 9 years ago
> > However, I've just put /dev/vkd0a in /etc/fstab and it works too.
> > Is 's0' somehow added by mount or the kernel?
> The root mount information does not come from /etc/fstab :)
Fair enough. I forgot I'm passing -r /var/vkernel/rootimg.01 to
vkernel everytime I'm starting it :-).
According to init_disk() in src/sys/platform/vkernel/platform/init.c,
the root virtual disk is associated with vkd0s0a. So I reckon my
patch makes sense.
Anybody knows what /etc/fstab is used for in the vkernel env?
#8 Updated by c.turner about 9 years ago
Any other mounted filesystems as usual..
see /etc/rc.d/mountcritlocal, etc.
The vkernel boots on the first partition in the vkd by default,
see init_vkd in sys/platform/vkernel/platform/init.c:705
(sets to vkd0s0a for VKD_DISK and cd9660:vcd0a for VKD_CD)
Probably good to have fstab and the docs match something that works
(as discussed elsewhere)
in case you want the shorthand to 'mount -o rw /'
after an unclean shutdown, mount -a from vcd booted chroot,
#11 Updated by dillon about 9 years ago
:Well, when I "ls /dev/vkd0*", I get:
:/dev/vkd0 /dev/vkds0 /dev/vkds0a ...
:There is no /dev/vkd0a printed.
:First time I configured the vkernel, I referred to an old version of
:vkernel.7 and had to manually add 's0' to some other commands so after
:checking /dev as shown above I added it in /etc/fstab too and it's
:been running ok since.
:However, I've just put /dev/vkd0a in /etc/fstab and it works too.
:Is 's0' somehow added by mount or the kernel?
The manual page is definitely wrong, it needs to be vkd0s0a. It works
because even though the manual page is wrong, the vkernel doesn't
actually use the '/' entry in /etc/fstab to figure out what to do.
But it does create confusion so I'm fixing it right now.